Americans have plenty of leisure time because academics tell us so.
The Economist ran a story (The land of leisure, February 4th) suggesting we, in America, have plenty of time off. The article is based on the findings of Mr. Aguiar, an economist, and Mr. Hurst from the Graduate School of Business at the University of Chicago. It is no surprise that the discussion around leisure becomes quantitative. I’m sure both gentlemen are very good at counting.
The basis of the studies came from time-use diaries. This method does inform us - but only to a point.
The learned gents argue that Americans have more leisure time than previously thought. They have collected data to prove it. I mentioned the study to my stepdaughter in New York. She works full-time, is in her thirties, married with a young child. Her indignant response was, “ I’m sure no woman ever wrote for the Economist!”
It’s not easy to understand the difference between work and leisure. We don’t have an adequate definition of either. Of course, studies are only correct until something else disproves them. Employment figures released by the Bureau of Labor Statistics don’t tell the whole story. Those numbers don’t account for people who have given up looking for work, are otherwise unable to work, or the long-term desperate. We know about what we measure, but not much else.
From anecdotal evidence, there are many of us who spend vast amounts of time, preparing for work, traveling to work, and actually working. My wife can spend a huge amount of time in the bathroom getting ready for work. I know this because I have conducted my own long-term study. But we must be careful not to denigrate work. Any culture that does not honor work is doomed – but we do have a tendency to overdo it.
We live in a culture of quantity. Josef Pieper’s seminal book, Leisure: The Basis of Culture warned us against the “Total World of Work.”
A vacation can be a respite from work. But if all a vacation gives us is enough renewal to go back to work, its function is limited. We vacate on a vacation: We go somewhere else. The notion is of retreat. Two weeks of activity, even in an exotic location, is unlikely to change the way we see the world.
Our culture is based on action. But action without the time to consider is dangerous. How many of us simply are working or being entertained? Let’s not confuse entertainment and leisure.
If we don’t experience a positive and beneficial state of doing nothing, we won’t value it. Slowing down has its dangers. There is a reason some of us need the constant companionship of the TV; the radio playing in the car; the avoidance of silence. There is a terror of being alone. What might we find out?
According to one source, leisure time is that for which you would not choose to pay someone else to spend for you. For example, you wouldn’t pay someone to go on vacation for you. Or would you? I am not so sure that paying someone to go on vacation for you is all that absurd. Some vacations are used to fulfill familial obligations. Some vacations can be devoid of all enjoyment. There is a reason for those mother-in-law jokes. There is the phenomenon of “vacation stress.” Many people experience discomfort around holidays. Some escape into the world of work: It can be less emotionally demanding.
Workaholism is socially acceptable even if potentially damaging. It’s tough to have an interesting conversation with a one–dimensional workaholic. Fortunately, the art of conversation is not quite dead in America.
If Americans, under the retirement age, really have more leisure, where are they? How many people do you know who have the time and engage in non-commercial hobbies? It is as if a large part of our culture is against private enjoyment. Our identities are based on work. The term “professional” is seen as having more social value than “amateur.” But a professional works for money. The amateur (from the French word to love) engages in an activity purely out of interest, out of curiosity: for pleasure.
Rather than talk about how much leisure, maybe we should talk about how it enriches our quality of life.